China is in the news again this week (when is it NOT) as high ranking officials visit Washington; while the People’s Bank back in Beijing announce yet another series of policy measures aimed at reigning in rampant speculation.
People’s Bank of China Governor Zhou Xiaochuan – Fed Chairman Bernanke’s Chinese counterpart – visited with politicians this week and said all the right things. Mr. Zhou pledged that China intends to “follow the three principles of exchange-rate reform and increase the flexibility of the yuan.”
Of course actions speak louder than words, so late last week and certainly timed to coincide perfectly with the Chinese road-trip, the People’s Bank increased the “official” range in which its currency (the yuan) is allowed to move each day against the U.S. dollar. The currency trading band was increased to 0.5% above the official target exchange rate, up from 0.3% previously. Not a very big move – or a real big surprise.
People’s Bank Knows How to Talk the Talk
Perhaps the People’s Bank has taken a page from former Fed Chief Alan Greenspan’s playbook. They’re getting good at jawboning, accompanied by well-timed policy moves, while at all times remaining very cryptic about their real intentions.
In addition to the exchange-rate move, China also raised bank deposit reserve requirements, while raising both official lending rates, and bank deposit rates. In doing so, China is still trying to quell the speculative froth building in mainland asset markets. But their method is the same as always – moving in baby steps.
The People’s Bank hopes to soak-up some of the excess money sloshing around China and redirect it into bank deposits – rather than stock brokerage accounts. But so far, there’s little sign of success, as most stock indexes continue to surge to record highs.
Meanwhile, Chinese savers still receive only 3% interest on the Chinese equivalent of a one-year CD, which isn’t much of an incentive compared to stock market gains of 130% last year.
The Real China Show is Changing Channels
The increase in deposit and lending rates, just like the widening of its currency exchange rate, looks a lot like window dressing to me. It’s a circus side-show designed to entertain the media, because they just can’t get enough of the China story.
But as I stated in a previous post (China (Finally) Moves to Help Level the Playing Field for Mainland Investors) the real story in China is Beijing’s recent move to significantly relax investment restrictions on hundreds of millions of mainland investors – and that’s where the real money can be made too.
China’s CSI 300 Index, of mainland listed A-shares is up nearly 90% year to date, but performance has been uneven in recent weeks. In fact, the more speculative Shanghai B share index, which can ONLY be traded by domestic individuals and overseas investors, plunged 5% the other day; the steepest drop in three months.
Expect a Great Wall of Chinese Cash to Move Offshore
The reason appears simple; China’s investment authorities recently cleared the way for mainland investors to move up to 50% of investment assets into overseas markets, through qualified institutional accounts. And it would appear that millions of Chinese investors are already making this move. And why not; after all there is a very big valuation incentive to do so.
China’s A-shares are trading at more than 43 times earnings, which looks rather pricey when compared to the recent past. But in Hong Kong, China’s H-share index trades at just 20 times last year’s profits – and only 15 times next year’s expected earnings. What a bargain!
I estimate that Chinese firms listed in Hong Kong are now about 50% cheaper than the very same company shares listed in Shanghai. That’s like a half-off sale in Hong Kong equities compared to Shanghai. And I expect this valuation gap between the two markets to start closing fast – and in favor of Hong Kong.
After all, with such a glaring valuation advantage - and with China’s mainland investors funding nearly nine million new brokerage accounts in the first-quarter alone – where do you think most of this cash is likely to flow?
The “Mad Rush” into H-shares
In the month of April alone, Chinese retail investors pumped about 175 billion yuan of fresh-cash into stocks! My contacts in Hong Kong recently weighed in with their views on what this means for investing in China going forward.
Ushe Koh, VP of private banking at DBS Bank Ltd believes these moves will “ABSOLUTELY” (his emphasis) lead to increased flow of investment assets to Hong Kong. In Ushe’s worlds, it’s all “part of the whole mad rush for investments” in China, and he sees most of this windfall directed at Hong Kong’s blue-chip shares.
My colleague Jack Flader, CEO of Global Consultants and Services in Hong Kong, tried to subdue his enthusiasm stating wisely that “the hype is always bigger than the reality”.
BUT, Jack went on to say that even if you were to discount the hype by half, the reality could mean cash inflows to Hong Kong shares equivalent to one-third “of the current total stock exchange market cap. HUGE!!!” Again, the emphasis is all his.
The bottom line, as Jack aptly puts it, is that “Hong Kong is buzzing from China’s latest ‘gift’.”
As I explained to my Global Market Investor subscribers recently, Hong Kong is a wonderful, yet often overlooked back-door into the vast profit potential of China. And it’s a market that’s also a much better value than Shanghai.
In fact, I just recommended two very attractive ways to invest in Hong Kong’s H-share market. These ETFs are still a screaming bargain right now compared with the A-shares – and will definitely participate in the long-term upside gains from China’s tremendous growth.